The French Connection: plutonium problems in France linked to Duke’s Catawba reactor & the Savannah River Site MOX plant

Hello Savannah River Site watchers –   

SRSOctober 16, 2009 –

You may have seen some news about a serious problem at a plutonium facility in Cadarche, France, which is under the control of the Commissariat à l’énergie atomique (CEA, French Atomic Energy Commission).  This facility, the Atelier de Technologie du Plutonium (ATPu), produced plutonium fuel (MOX) and is being cleaned out and decommissioned.  Due to poor accounting methods of the plutonium in the facility, it was discovered that the build-up of plutonium had reached amounts of concern for a nuclear criticality incident, which has been big news in France.  

Without going into more details, I wanted to remind you that the ATPu facility manufactured US test MOX fuel pellets which were inserted into “lead test assemblies” (LTAs) from US weapons-grade plutonium from Los Alamos which had been shipped by sea via the Charleston(SC) Nuclear Weapons Station.  The French-made MOX LTAs were shipped back via Charleston in 2005 and tested in Duke Energy’s Catawba Unit 1 reactor near Rock Hill, SC.  That test failed when the LTAs performed poorly and were withdrawn after two 18-month fueling cycle instead of the three 18-month cycles which were needed.  

The ATPu facility could well have a bit of US plutonium involved in the current incident, but it more importantly reveals just how easy it is to “lose” a serious amount of plutonium in a MOX facility, enough to cause a dreaded unplanned nuclear reaction.  (Are you paying attention, SRS MOX plant backers?)  

Now, with an outage of the Catawba Unit 1 reactor set to start around November 20, has the US plutonium cabal modified the French-manufactured MOX LTAs for reinsertion for that third cycle they missed?  Or, is Duke over with dealing with the shite MOX and now DOE has to continue to scramble to sucker other utilities, like TVA, into using MOX?

Have a plutonium-free day! Tom  Clement,  SRS -Action

News release on the Pu problem from the L’Autorité de sûreté nucléaire (ASN)  – Nuclear Safety Authority:


Incident at the nuclear facility dealing with Plutonium technology (CEACadarache plant)

On 6 October 2009, the Commissariat à l’Energie Atomique (CEA) notified ASN of an incident occurred at the nuclear facility dealing with Plutonium technology and so-called “Atelier de Technologie du Plutonium” ATPu located in the CEA Cadarache plant. The ATPu, a facility currently being dismantled, is operated by AREVA NC and the license holder of this facility is the CEA.

The CEA informed ASN that the amount of plutonium deposits in the facility glove boxes was underestimated. The amount of plutonium deposits during the facility operation was estimated to about 8 kg by the CEA. The amount of plutonium collected during dismantling activities greatly exceeds this value and is currently reaching 22kg. According to CEA, it could come to 39 kg.

Following this notification, ASN performed a comprehensive inspection at the ATPu facility on 9 October 2009. This inspection confirmed that the CEA has been aware of this incident since June 2009.

Moreover, ASN requested its technical support organization, IRSN, to carry out an expertise analysis which has been issued on 13 October. On 14 October 2009, the ASN Commission decided to suspend the ATPu facility dismantling activities, pending the verification of fissile material accountability (ASN Commission decision No. 2009-160 of 14 October 2009).

This incident has no impact on the environment nor on the public. However, the underestimation of the amount of plutonium has led to deeply reduce the security margins provided by the facility design to prevent a criticality accident.

ASN has sent a record to the public prosecutor for failure to observe the terms of incident notification, as prescribed by regulations.

ASN considers that the failure to detect this underestimation of fissile material amounts during dismantling activities and the late notification of this incident to ASN have revealed weaknesses in the safety culture of both the licensee and the operator.

Consequently, ASN has decided to rate this incident at level 2 on the INES scale. The ATPu facility had been operated for 40 years and its main activity had been the production of MOX fuel. The decree of 6 March 2009 authorized the permanent shutdown of this facility and its immediate dismantling.  



Filed under Environmental, Nuclear materials, Nuclear waste, South Carolina

3 responses to “The French Connection: plutonium problems in France linked to Duke’s Catawba reactor & the Savannah River Site MOX plant

  1. Pingback: Critical build-up of plutonium in France’s nuclear plant « nuclear-news

  2. was not aware there where problems with nuclear power in France.. I know us Americans are the ones who showed them how to use it … thanks

  3. Steve

    Too bad that the author failed to understand the basics about nuclear material and criticality. There is no safety connection between material hold up in a French facility and the LTA materials inserted into an American nuclear reactor..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s